Skip to main content
logo for bnsf - attempt 1
logo for bnsf - attempt 1
logo for bnsf - attempt 1

What BNSF Filed – and Why

Our Nov. 18 filing: Why the merger should be denied, and what customers would need if it isn't

On Nov. 18, BNSF filed comments with the STB urging it to deny the proposed Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern merger.

Our position hasn't changed. The merger would cause significant harm to competition and customers, and its promised benefits don't hold up. It relies on unrealistic growth projections and overstated operating benefits. The applicants' proposed fixes fall short, including their gateway pricing commitment, targeted access and rate arbitration offers.

The STB has asked stakeholders to identify what would be needed if the merger moves forward, so our filing also lays out conditions. Let us be clear: these conditions are necessary, but they are not enough. At best, they would only partly offset the merger's harm. They cannot replace the competition that would be lost. BNSF continues to firmly believe the merger should be denied.

Read our STB Filings here

Here's what we requested and why each matters to customers:

1. Protecting Competition for Northeast Intermodal Shipments

Today, BNSF and NS efficiently move consumer goods together between West Coast ports and markets in Pennsylvania and the Northeast, giving customers a competitive choice. The merger would shut BNSF out of that supply chain, put one railroad—Union Pacific—in control of that entire transcontinental corridor.

What we requested and why: The right to run BNSF trains on Norfolk Southern track from Chicago to Pennsylvania, plus access to Norfolk Southern intermodal terminals, preserving a competitive option for customers shipping between the West Coast and Northeast.

Read more

2. Preserving Choice on the Gulf Coast

The Gulf Coast is home to one of the country's largest concentrations of chemical, plastics and energy facilities, and many of them depend on competition between railroads.

What we requested: A neutral terminal railroad, meaning one independent operator that connects all customers facilities in the region to both Union Pacific and BNSF, allowing both railroads to compete for their business

Read more

Sunset Over Railroad Tracks

3. Keeping interline routes competitive

Many shipments move on more than one railroad. After a merger, the combined railroad could manipulate price or service for those shared routes in ways that push freight onto its own single-line network and away from competitors.

What we requested: An Interline Preservation Mechanism that's permanent and has no restrictions. It differs from the UP’s flawed gateway proposals in several ways:

  • It covers all traffic. No commodity or train type is left out.
  • It covers all affected customers. It applies to shipments between BNSF-served locations and facilities that only Norfolk Southern serves today, whether directly or through a shortline railroad.
  • It works at any existing interchange.
  • It ties rates to an objective benchmark. BNSF's share of the rate would be based on the average of what Union Pacific earns on comparable traffic. The benchmark would be updated every quarter.
  • It eases the transition. Today's gateway rates would remain available for five years, making sure that supply chain plans in place for years aren’t disrupted on day one.

4. Opening access for captive customers

Many facilities can only be served by one railroad. The merger would make that problem worse.

What we requested: Facilities served by only Union Pacific, Norfolk Southern or one of their affiliated short lines would gain access to another railroad if they're within 20 miles of an active interchange with another major railroad. Under this arrangement, the current railroad would move cars to or from the second railroad for a fee. This would also apply to locations that qualify in the future.

  • Fair, transparent pricing. The switching fee would be based on cost, publicly available and updated every year.
  • Equal service. Service would be at least as good as what the incumbent railroad gives its own traffic. It would be measured against existing STB service standards and overseen by an independent compliance monitor.

Read more

5. Additional conditions

BNSF also proposed targeted protections to preserve customer access and competition at critical rail hubs and shared facilities:

  • TTX railcar pool: UP would need to keep its ownership of TTX, the industry's shared railcar company, below 50%. Major corporate decisions would require a two-thirds supermajority vote.
  • New Orleans: An independent, neutral dispatcher for the Huey P. Long Bridge and the Back Belt.
  • Memphis: Removing any agreements that could block construction of the Kentucky Street connection between BNSF and CSX.
  • Terminal Railroad Association of St. Louis (TRRA) and Kansas City Terminal Railway (KCT): BNSF does not oppose the proposed transfer of Norfolk Southern's ownership interests in these terminal railroads to CN.

Read more

Merger Conditions Factsheets

Northeast Intermodal: Protecting the Consumer

Gulf Coast: Protecting the Industrial Economy

Interline Preservation: Keeping Routes Competitive

Open Access: Choice for One-Railroad Customers

Protections for Key Rail Hubs and Shared Resources

The Bottom line

These conditions would reduce some of the harm. They would not make this merger good for customers, competition or the economy. BNSF will continue to urge the STB to deny it.